I Know What You Did Last Summer is slick, occasionally self-aware, and made by people who get what made the original tick—even if they can’t quite replicate it ...

He’s got a hook for a hand but can still write the seven words in steam on a bathroom mirror: “I Know What You Did Last ...

“Finally Dawn” is at its most intriguing as Costanzo entrusts his curly haired, wide-eyed naïf to maneuver the looking glass ...